It looks like Kristin Cavallari and Jay Cutler are going to have a little boy!

The Chicago Bears quarterback and the reality star announced they’re expecting their first child together back in January, but the parents-to-be weren’t the ones who spilled the big news about the baby’s gender.

Cutler’s teammate, Earl Bennett, let the secret slip on WSCR-AM 670’s “The Boers & Bernstein Show.”

“New toys, a baby on the way – he’s having a boy – I’m excited for Jay,” he said. “It’s a great time.”

The longtime couple has had a few rough patches – they were engaged last year, but called off the wedding and split briefly before reuniting in November. However, they’re engaged again and seem stronger than ever.

In previous interviews, Cavallari, 25, talked about their plans for the future:

“We want four kids, so we’re thinking maybe have one more, then get married, then have two more, but we’ll see, it all depends on how the first one goes.”